Persona 4: The Privacy Advocate

Focus: GDPR, Surveillance, Data Sovereignty, Ethics.

1. Surveillance & Ethics
1. Are you building a surveillance tool for stalkers?
We build "Memory for the First User," not "Surveillance of Others." Our terms of service and UI emphasize consent. Audio recording has visual indicators. We are creating a tool for introspection, not espionage.
2. What if a government subpoenas your data to prosecute a user?
They get a pile of encrypted nonsense. Because we use client-side encryption, we do not possess the private keys. We cannot decrypt user data even under court order. This "Warrant Canary" architecture is fundamental to our trust model.
3. "Passive listening" implies you are always recording. That is a wiretap.
We do not record 24/7 by default. We use "VAD" (Voice Activity Detection) and geofencing. Users can whitelist specific locations (e.g., Office, Home) and blacklist others (e.g., Bedroom). The user is the ultimate gatekeeper of the microphone.
2. Data Ownership
4. Who owns the vectors? You or me?
You do. The vectors are a derivative work of your personal data. Our EULA explicitly states that the user retains 100% ownership of both raw media and the generated semantic index.
5. What happens when you get acquired by Facebook?
This is the "WhatsApp Scenario." We are creating a "Poison Pill" in our data architecture. Because the keys are on user devices, an acquirer cannot perform a retroactive mass-scan of existing data without breaking the encryption—which requires user permission.
6. Can I host my own server?
Yes. We will offer a "Self-Hosted Docker" option for the technical privacy extremists. They can run the synchronization server on their own NAS (Example: Synology or Raspberry Pi), bypassing our cloud entirely.
3. Risk Mitigation
7. What if your S3 bucket leaks?
It would leak encrypted blobs associated with random UUIDs. Without the client-side keys (which are never on S3), the data is statistically indistinguishable from noise. PII is minimal.
8. Does the AI train on my data to improve the model for others?
Absolutely not. We do not use user data for "Global Model Training." Your data remains in your local inference sandbox. We improve our models using public datasets and paid, consenting testers.
9. What if a hacker gets my phone?
Biometric lock (FaceID/Fingerprint) on app launch. Additionally, the encryption keys are in the Secure Enclave—even with physical access, extraction is nearly impossible without your biometric.
10. Can you see my search queries?
Only anonymized analytics ("User searched 5 times today"). Never the content of the query. Search queries are encrypted in transit to our cloud infrastructure and we don't log query contents.
4. Third Parties
11. Do you share data with advertisers?
No. We don't have ads. Our business model is subscription. Zero incentive to share data.
12. What about analytics providers (Google Analytics, Mixpanel)?
We use privacy-first analytics (PostHog self-hosted or Plausible). No third-party trackers. No cookies. Clean.
13. Do you sell aggregated/anonymized data?
No. Even "anonymized" data can be de-anonymized. We don't touch that business model.
14. What if your payment processor (Stripe) gets hacked?
Stripe handles payment data, not memory data. They're PCI-DSS compliant. Even if breached, they don't have access to your memories.
15. Do you use third-party cloud AI (OpenAI, Google)?
Yes, we use cloud AI APIs for AI processing. Privacy protections: 1) Media stays local on device, 2) Only necessary metadata sent (encrypted), 3) Zero retention - providers don't train on our API usage, 4) We're contractually bound to privacy-preserving practices. Cloud AI enables better features while maintaining privacy through architectural design.
5. Legal & Compliance
16. Are you GDPR compliant?
Yes. Right to access, rectification, erasure, portability—all built-in. We're also CCPA compliant for California.
17. How do I exercise my "Right to be Forgotten"?
One button: "Delete Account." All cloud data is cryptographically erased within 24 hours. We can't recover it even if we wanted to.
18. What data do you retain after I delete my account?
Only anonymous usage stats (for legal/tax purposes). Email hash (to prevent re-signup abuse). No personal content.
19. Do you comply with data localization laws (China, Russia)?
We don't operate in markets with invasive data localization requirements. If we enter China, it would be via a separate legal entity with explicit user consent.
20. What about COPPA (children's data)?
Under-13 requires parental consent. The parent creates a "Family Vault" and controls the child's data until they turn 13.
6. Trust & Transparency
21. Have you had any data breaches?
None. We're pre-launch. Post-launch, we'll publish a transparency report annually.
22. Will you notify me if there's a breach?
Within 72 hours (GDPR requirement). Email + in-app notification. Full disclosure.
23. Can I audit the code?
We're considering open-sourcing the encryption layer. For now, third-party security audits (published publicly) provide verification.
24. Do you have a privacy policy a human can read?
Yes. Plain English, 2 pages max. No legalese traps. If you can't understand it, we've failed.
25. What if I disagree with a policy change?
We'll email 30 days in advance. You can export and delete before the change takes effect. No retroactive changes without consent.
7. Biometric Data
26. Facial recognition is creepy. How do you handle faces?
Face analysis happens via Gemini Vision API with privacy protections: faces are detected and matched, but biometric templates are encrypted. Media stays on your device. You can disable face recognition entirely in settings.
27. What about voice biometrics?
We transcribe voice to text using Gemini's speech-to-text. The audio file is stored locally, encrypted. We don't extract voiceprints for identification (that's surveillance tech). Transcription happens via secure API, original audio never leaves device unencrypted.
28. Can I use Dzikra without any biometric data?
Yes. Disable face recognition, use text-only search. It's less magical but fully functional.
29. What about location data?
GPS coordinates are stored locally. If you sync to cloud, they're encrypted. You can disable location tagging entirely in settings.
30. Do you track my movement patterns?
No. We store location per photo, not continuous tracking. We're not building a movement heatmap.
8. Consent & Control
31. Can I record others without their knowledge?
Technically yes, but it's unethical and potentially illegal (wiretap laws). We encourage transparency. The UI has visual indicators when recording.
32. What if someone asks me to delete their memories?
You can "Mute" or "Delete" specific people from your index. Their faces/voices won't surface. It's your memory; you control it.
33. Can someone opt-out of being in my Dzikra?
Not technically (it's your data), but ethically, yes. We provide "Blur Face" tools for sensitive cases.
34. What about workplace surveillance? Employers forcing employees to use this?
We actively discourage this. Our TOS prohibits coercive use. Dzikra is for personal empowerment, not corporate control.
35. Do I need to consent to AI processing?
Yes. On first launch, you accept terms. You can toggle specific AI features (face recognition, voice transcription) individually.
9. International
36. What about countries with weak privacy laws?
Our architecture protects you regardless. Even in a jurisdiction with no privacy laws, the encryption prevents local access.
37. Can authoritarian regimes force you to build a backdoor?
We'd refuse and exit that market. We won't compromise the global architecture for one region.
38. What if you get a National Security Letter (NSL)?
We'd comply with providing metadata ("User X exists") but cannot decrypt content. We'd challenge gag orders legally.
39. Do you operate in the EU?
Yes. We use EU-based cloud regions for EU users (data residency). Full GDPR compliance.
40. What about Schrems II (EU-US data transfers)?
We use Standard Contractual Clauses (SCCs) and encryption. EU data stays in EU data centers where possible.
10. Ethical AI
41. Can your AI be biased?
Yes. We audit for bias regularly (facial recognition accuracy across races, genders). We publish bias reports annually.
42. What if the AI misidentifies someone (false positive)?
Users can correct. Each correction improves the personal model. We show confidence scores to signal uncertainty.
43. Do you use facial recognition from clearview AI or similar?
Absolutely not. We only recognize faces you have photographed. No external databases.
44. Can your AI manipulate my emotions?
We design against dark patterns. No "infinite scroll," no manipulative notifications. The goal is utility, not addiction.
45. What if the AI "gaslights" me? Telling me I said something I didn't?
We always cite sources. If Dzikra says "You said X," it shows the timestamp and audio snippet. Verification is built-in.
11. Family & Sharing
46. If I share memories with family, can they see everything?
No. You share specific "Memory Capsules," not your entire vault. Granular control.
47. What if my spouse demands access to my Dzikra?
That's a relationship issue, not a tech one. We don't facilitate spousal surveillance. Your vault is yours.
48. Can I create a joint account?
No joint accounts (security risk). But you can share "Family Memories" where both contribute and both have access.
49. What happens to shared memories if I delete my account?
Your contributions are removed from the shared space. Others' copies remain (they own their perspective).
50. Can children's data be accessed by parents?
Until age 13 (COPPA), yes. After 13, the child gains full control and can revoke parental access.
12. Death & Legacy
51. What happens to my data when I die?
You designate a "Legacy Contact" (like Apple). They can access your vault after death with legal proof (death certificate).
52. Can I set an auto-delete after death?
Yes. "Digital Will" feature. Set policies: delete all, transfer to family, or archive publicly (with consent).
53. What if I don't designate a legacy contact?
After 2 years of inactivity, we send warnings. After 3 years, account is frozen. After 5 years, deleted (per GDPR).
54. Can my memories be used in my will?
Yes. You own your data. You can legally transfer ownership via a will.
55. What about wrongful death cases? Can lawyers subpoena?
Yes, but they'll get encrypted data. Only the deceased's legacy contact has the keys. We can't decrypt.
13. Emerging Concerns
56. What about AI deepfakes? Can someone fabricate my memories?
We use C2PA digital signatures. Memories captured via Dzikra are cryptographically signed. Tampered data is flagged.
57. Can insurance companies demand access to my memories?
Not without a court order. We fight overbroad requests. Your memories aren't for sale to insurers.
58. What about divorce proceedings? Spouse's lawyer subpoenaing?
Possible. We comply with lawful subpoenas. But again: encrypted data. The spouse needs your key.
59. Can Dzikra be used for elder abuse (tracking elderly parents)?
This is why consent is critical. Elderly users must actively consent. Coercive installations violate TOS.
60. What about stalking? Ex-partners abusing this?
We have abuse detection (unusual access patterns). Victims can lock accounts immediately. We work with safety orgs.
14. Future-Proofing
61. What if encryption standards break in 20 years?
We'll migrate to post-quantum encryption. Your data is re-encrypted with new standards transparently.
62. What if the company goes bankrupt?
Your local data remains intact. Cloud data can be exported before shutdown. We'll give 90 days notice.
63. What if you pivot to ads later?
We can't. The architecture doesn't support it (data is encrypted). Pivoting to ads would require rebuilding from scratch.
64. Will you ever sell user data?
No. It's in our founding charter. If the company is acquired, this clause remains binding.
65. How do I verify you're not lying about privacy?
Third-party audits (published), open-source encryption library, bug bounty program. Trust, but verify.
15. Philosophy
66. Why should I trust a startup with my life's memories?
Because we designed the system to not require trust. Even if we turn evil, the encryption protects you. Trustless by design.
67. Isn't "privacy" just marketing?
For most companies, yes. For us, it's the foundation. Without privacy, Dzikra is just surveillance. We can't afford to compromise.
68. What's your stance on government surveillance?
We oppose mass surveillance. We support targeted, lawful investigations. We fight overbroad warrants in court.
69. Do you lobby for privacy laws?
Yes. We support strong privacy regulation (GDPR-style globally). Good regulation helps users and ethical companies.
70. What's your response to "I have nothing to hide"?
Privacy isn't about hiding. It's about control. You own your story; no one else should profit from it without consent.
16. Extreme Scenarios
71. What if a hacker group targets Dzikra specifically?
They'd get encrypted blobs. Without user keys (device-side), the data is useless. Our bounty is low compared to centralized systems.
72. What if an employee goes rogue?
Role-based access control. No single employee can access user data. Even admins see only anonymized metadata.
73. What if AI becomes sentient and reads my memories?
Then we have bigger problems than Dzikra. But seriously: the AI processes locally. It doesn't "know" you beyond your device.
74. What if quantum computers break encryption tomorrow?
We'd emergency-patch with post-quantum algorithms. It's a race, but we're monitoring NIST standards closely.
75. What if the internet goes down forever?
Your local data remains accessible. Dzikra is "offline-first." The cloud is a luxury, not a dependency.
17. Final Assurances
76. Can you prove your encryption works?
We'll publish technical whitepapers and invite cryptographers to audit. "Prove" is hard, but we'll get as close as possible.
77. What's your privacy score vs competitors?
Google Photos: D (monetizes data). Apple Photos: B (closed ecosystem). Dzikra: A (zero-access, open about tradeoffs).
78. Will you sign a contract guaranteeing privacy?
Our TOS is a contract. If we violate it, you can sue. We're happy to include specific privacy SLAs for enterprise customers.
79. What's your worst-case privacy scenario?
Catastrophic key management bug exposes a user's keys. We'd disclose immediately, offer forensics support, and compensate affected users.
80. Last question: Why should I believe you?
Don't. Verify. Check our architecture. Read the audits. Test the export tools. We designed Dzikra so you don't have to trust us. That's the point.